The selection of an appropriate root canal obturation technique is important for maintaining the structural integrity of endodontically treated teeth. However, little research is available that compares the fracture resistance and dentinal crack propagation between bioceramic-based obturation techniques. Objective: To compare the fracture resistance and crack propagation in mandibular premolars obturated using single-cone and warm vertical compaction techniques with a bioceramic sealer. Methods: An in vitro comparative experimental study was designed involving 151 extracted human mandibular premolars. Two groups of specimens were allocated, one of single-cone and the other of warm vertical compaction (n=76 and n=75, respectively). The dentinal cracks were evaluated by micro-computed tomography before and after biomechanical preparation and after obturation. The fracture resistance was determined by a universal testing machine. A p-value of < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results: The mean fracture resistance was greater in the single-cone group (812 ± 145 N) compared to the warm vertical compaction group (768 ± 152 N), but not statistically different (p=0.071). The incidence of post-obturation cracks was 40.8% and 52.0%, respectively (p=0.223). The mean crack propagation length for the warm vertical compaction group (0.55 ± 0.22 mm) was significantly higher than that for the single-cone group (0.42 ± 0.18 mm; p=0.008). There was no difference across groups (p=0.750) in fracture patterns. Conclusion: There was no statistically significant difference in the overall fracture resistance between the two obturation methods. Warm vertical compaction demonstrated greater mean crack propagation length, warranting further investigation.
Endodontic treatment aims to preserve natural teeth by eliminating pulpal infection, disinfecting the root canal system, and providing an effective three-dimensional seal.[1] The integrity of endodontically treated teeth, however, can be jeopardized by tooth structure removal through access cavity preparation, mechanical instrumentation, chemical irrigation, and obturation procedures.[2] These changes can decrease the resistance to functional occlusal loading of the radicular dentin, leading to problems of dentinal cracks and vertical root fractures.[2] Vertical root fracture is a challenging
complication in post-endodontic treatment due to its challenging diagnosis, unfavourable prognosis, and frequent extraction of the tooth.[3] Maintenance of mechanical integrity of the root-filled tooth is thus an important factor to be considered in the choice of suitable obturation materials and techniques.[4]
The structural behaviour of endodontically treated teeth is highly dependent on the types of root canal obturation. Its single cone feature, low compaction forces from instrumentation, and its use with modern bioceramic sealers have made the material popular.[5] Warm vertical compaction, on the other hand, produces thermoplasticized gutta-percha, which can conform to irregularities and complexities of the canal, but the use of heat and vertical pressure could affect the distribution of stress in radicular dentin.[6] A systematic review and network meta-analysis conducted in 2024 that included 48 trials and 2,724 single-canal roots showed that vertical root fracture resistance was ranked highest with the single-cone technique at 70.2%, while vertical compaction was ranked at 53.0%.[7] However, there was no statistically significant difference between the main obturation techniques when they were compared directly, suggesting that none of the techniques is superior.
In addition to catastrophic fracture resistance, development and propagation of dentinal microcracks are important markers of the mechanical safety of the obturation procedure.[8] Unless the defect in dentine is repaired, it may act as a stress concentration point and lead to crack propagation under future functional loading. A micro-computed tomography examination of 60 extracted mandibular premolars showed Chellapilla et al. (2021) that 33.33% of the specimens had dentinal microcracks after biomechanical preparation.[9] Interestingly, when condensation is performed in the direction of warm vertical condensation, no additional increase in the number of cracks was seen, while a 1.66% increase was seen in the number of cracks for cold lateral condensation, but the difference was not statistically significant.[9] Crack development under these conditions is emphasized by these findings, which show that non-destructive imaging methods are important and useful to evaluate crack development in addition to conventional fracture testing. In addition, fracture resistance and crack propagation are related but different mechanical properties, and examining both may yield a better understanding of the structural effects of obturation.
Although there is growing evidence in the literature concerning the fracture resistance of bioceramic-based obturation systems, an important question still remains: does the obturation technique that offers higher fracture resistance also reduce dentinal crack initiation and propagation. The literature on fracture resistance or the formation of dentinal microcracks has been published mainly as isolated variables; however, there is still limited evidence that has compared fracture resistance with dentinal microcrack formation in mandibular premolars with the same bioceramic sealer. This is clinically significant because this higher fracture load may not necessarily correspond to a lower tendency for crack development. The aim of the present study was therefore to compare the fracture resistance and fracture propagation of the extracted human mandibular premolars obturated with the single-cone and warm vertical compaction methods with a bioceramic sealer. This study was designed to assess both mechanical strength and dentinal integrity to provide clinically relevant data for the selection of an obturation technique that will preserve radicular dentin to the greatest extent and minimize the potential for post-endodontic root fracture.
Endodontic treatment aims to preserve natural teeth by eliminating pulpal infection, disinfecting the root canal system, and providing an effective three-dimensional seal.[1] The integrity of endodontically treated teeth, however, can be jeopardized by tooth structure removal through access cavity preparation, mechanical instrumentation, chemical irrigation, and obturation procedures.[2] These changes can decrease the resistance to functional occlusal loading of the radicular dentin, leading to problems of dentinal cracks and vertical root fractures.[2] Vertical root fracture is a challenging complication in post-endodontic treatment due to its challenging diagnosis, unfavourable prognosis, and frequent extraction of the tooth.[3] Maintenance of mechanical integrity of the root-filled tooth is thus an important factor to be considered in the choice of suitable obturation materials and techniques.[4]
The structural behaviour of endodontically treated teeth is highly dependent on the types of root canal obturation. Its single cone feature, low compaction forces from instrumentation, and its use with modern bioceramic sealers have made the material popular.[5] Warm vertical compaction, on the other hand, produces thermoplasticized gutta-percha, which can conform to irregularities and complexities of the canal, but the use of heat and vertical pressure could affect the distribution of stress in radicular dentin.[6] A systematic review and network meta-analysis conducted in 2024 that included 48 trials and 2,724 single-canal roots showed that vertical root fracture resistance was ranked highest with the single-cone technique at 70.2%, while vertical compaction was ranked at 53.0%.[7] However, there was no statistically significant difference between the main obturation techniques when they were compared directly, suggesting that none of the techniques is superior.
In addition to catastrophic fracture resistance, development and propagation of dentinal microcracks are important markers of the mechanical safety of the obturation procedure.[8] Unless the defect in dentine is repaired, it may act as a stress concentration point and lead to crack propagation under future functional loading. A micro-computed tomography examination of 60 extracted mandibular premolars showed Chellapilla et al. (2021) that 33.33% of the specimens had dentinal microcracks after biomechanical preparation.[9] Interestingly, when condensation is performed in the direction of warm vertical condensation, no additional increase in the number of cracks was seen, while a 1.66% increase was seen in the number of cracks for cold lateral condensation, but the difference was not statistically significant.[9] Crack development under these conditions is emphasized by these findings, which show that non-destructive imaging methods are important and useful to evaluate crack development in addition to conventional fracture testing. In addition, fracture resistance and crack propagation are related but different mechanical properties, and examining both may yield a better understanding of the structural effects of obturation.
Although there is growing evidence in the literature concerning the fracture resistance of bioceramic-based obturation systems, an important question still remains: does the obturation technique that offers higher fracture resistance also reduce dentinal crack initiation and propagation. The literature on fracture resistance or the formation of dentinal microcracks has been published mainly as isolated variables; however, there is still limited evidence that has compared fracture resistance with dentinal microcrack formation in mandibular premolars with the same bioceramic sealer. This is clinically significant because this higher fracture load may not necessarily correspond to a lower tendency for crack development. The aim of the present study was therefore to compare the fracture resistance and fracture propagation of the extracted human mandibular premolars obturated with the single-cone and warm vertical compaction methods with a bioceramic sealer. This study was designed to assess both mechanical strength and dentinal integrity to provide clinically relevant data for the selection of an obturation technique that will preserve radicular dentin to the greatest extent and minimize the potential for post-endodontic root fracture.
The groups consisted of 76 specimens in the single-cone group (Group A) and 75 specimens in the warm vertical compaction group (Group B). A total of 151 mandibular premolars were used in this study. Baseline anatomical features such as root length, buccolingual diameter, and mesiodistal diameter were similar between the groups, and there were no statistically significant differences (p>0.05). (Table 1)
Radiographic evaluation showed good obturation in both groups. Of these, 90.8% and 89.3% had no voids in their homogeneous obturation or in their sections, respectively, and 96.1% and 96.0% had adequate filling length at the apex, respectively. (Table 2)
Micro-CT assessment showed that the percentage of dentinal cracks increased after the biomechanical preparation and obturation in both groups. The percentages of cracks found after obturation were 40.8% and 52.0% in Groups A and B, respectively. But there was no significant difference between these groups (p=0.223). (Table 3)
In the specimens that had cracks following obturation, the mean length of the cracks was significantly longer in the warm vertical compaction group (0.55 ± 0.22 mm) than in the single-cone group (0.42 ± 0.18 mm; p=0.008). However, there was no statistically significant difference in the percentage of specimens showing a higher crack length (p=0.274). (Table 4)
The fracture resistance of the single cone group (812 ± 145 N) was also significantly greater when compared with the warm vertical compaction group (768 ± 152 N). This difference, however, was not statistically significant (p=0.071; 95% CI: −3.9 to 91.9 N) between groups. (Table 5)
Concerning fracture patterns, horizontal fractures were the most common in both groups, followed by oblique and vertical root fractures. Vertical root fractures were observed in 11.8% and 14.7% of the specimens in each of group’s A and B, respectively. The overall distribution of fracture patterns, however, was not statistically different between the groups (p=0.750). (Table 6)
Table 1. Comparison of baseline anatomical characteristics of mandibular premolars between the two study groups
(n = 151)
|
Variables |
Group A: Single-cone (n=76) Mean ± SD |
Group B: Warm vertical (n=75) Mean ± SD |
p-value |
|
Root length (mm) |
20.1 ± 1.2 |
20.0 ± 1.1 |
0.594 |
|
Buccolingual root diameter (mm) |
6.8 ± 0.5 |
6.7 ± 0.5 |
0.221 |
|
Mesiodistal root diameter (mm) |
7.2 ± 0.6 |
7.1 ± 0.6 |
0.307 |
Table 2. Comparison of root canal preparation and obturation characteristics between the study groups
|
Variables |
Group A: Single-cone (n=76) |
Group B: Warm vertical (n=75) |
|
Root canal preparation |
|
|
|
Standardised final apical preparation achieved |
76 (100%) |
75 (100%) |
|
Standardised working length maintained |
76 (100%) |
75 (100%) |
|
Obturation quality |
|
|
|
Homogeneous obturation without visible voids |
69 (90.8%) |
67 (89.3%) |
|
Obturation with visible voids |
7 (9.2%) |
8 (10.7%) |
|
Adequate apical filling length |
73 (96.1%) |
72 (96.0%) |
|
Inadequate apical filling length |
3 (3.9%) |
3 (4.0%) |
Table 3. Comparison of dentinal crack incidence at different experimental stages using micro-computed tomography
|
Assessment stage |
Group A: Single-cone (n=76) |
Group B: Warm vertical (n=75) |
p-value |
|
Baseline assessment |
8 (10.5%) |
9 (12.0%) |
0.977 |
|
After biomechanical preparation |
20 (26.3%) |
25 (33.3%) |
0.444 |
|
After obturation |
31 (40.8%) |
39 (52.0%) |
0.223 |
|
No detectable cracks after obturation |
45 (59.2%) |
36 (48.0%) |
0.223 |
Table 4. Comparison of dentinal crack propagation characteristics between the study groups after obturation
|
Variables |
Group A: Single-cone |
Group B: Warm vertical |
p-value |
|
Specimens demonstrating crack propagation, n |
31 |
39 |
— |
|
Mean crack propagation length (mm) |
0.42 ± 0.18 |
0.55 ± 0.22 |
0.008 |
|
Specimens with increased crack length, n (%) |
23 (74.2%) |
33 (84.6%) |
0.274 |
|
Specimens with no measurable increase in crack length, n (%) |
8 (25.8%) |
6 (15.4%) |
0.274 |
Table 5. Comparison of fracture resistance between single-cone and warm vertical compaction techniques
|
Variables |
Group A: Single-cone (n=76) |
Group B: Warm vertical (n=75) |
p-value |
|
Mean fracture resistance (N) |
812 ± 145 |
768 ± 152 |
0.071 |
|
Minimum fracture load (N) |
485 |
430 |
— |
|
Maximum fracture load (N) |
1,165 |
1,120 |
— |
|
Mean difference (N) |
44 |
Reference |
— |
|
95% confidence interval for mean difference (N) |
-3.9 to 91.9 |
— |
— |
Table 6. Comparison of fracture patterns observed in mandibular premolars following mechanical loading
|
Fracture pattern |
Single-cone (n=76) |
Warm vertical (n=75) |
|
Horizontal fracture |
45 (59.2%) |
40 (53.3%) |
|
Oblique fracture |
22 (28.9%) |
24 (32.0%) |
|
Vertical root fracture |
9 (11.8%) |
11 (14.7%) |
|
Chi-square test: χ² = 0.574, p = 0.750. |
||
The present study compared the fracture resistance and dentinal crack propagation of obturated mandibular premolars using a single-cone and warm vertical compaction technique with a bioceramic sealer. The results showed a numerical difference in fracture resistance between the two techniques, with the mean value in the single-cone group (812 ± 145 N) higher than in the warm vertical compaction group (768 ± 152 N), but the difference did not reach the level of significance (p=0.071). The warm vertical compaction group (p=0.008) showed significantly higher length of crack propagation, however. The results shown here suggest that fracture resistance and crack propagation are independent mechanical responses and should not be interpreted as being inversely related.
The present study's higher numerical fracture resistance findings, using the single-cone technique, were similar to those of Al-Hyasat et al. (2023), who assessed the fracture resistance of endodontically treated roots after various sealers and obturation techniques. Their investigation showed that they were more favorable in fracture resistance than warm vertical compaction when using the single-cone technique, with this effect depending upon the sealer and obturation combination. Likewise, 60 single-rooted premolars were used in a 2025 experimental study, showing that the highest fracture resistance was achieved with a single-cone technique with a bioceramic sealer (600 ± 55 N), followed by warm vertical compaction (520 ± 45 N). Differences in the choice of teeth, instrumentation, sealer composition, and mechanical testing conditions, however, may affect the results, and these findings should be interpreted with caution.[10, 11]
However, Lichaa et al. (2022) found no statistically significant difference in fracture resistance between single-cone obturation (264.97 ± 83.98 N) and warm vertical compaction (313.35 ± 89.15 N), using the Bio-C sealer in mandibular incisors (p=0.159). The results obtained in their study were similar to the present study, and they determined that there was no significant difference in fracture resistance between the two techniques. The results show that despite the direction of the numerical change, the obturation technique alone might not always be able to predict the fracture resistance of different tooth types.[12]
The fracture resistance of mandibular premolars was examined by Şirinoğlu and Kaşıkçı (2025) to see how instrumentation taper and bioceramic sealer formulation affect the fracture resistance of mandibular premolars. They found that the geometry of the instrument and the composition of the sealer are important factors to consider when assessing the mechanical behaviour of root-filled teeth. This is especially important for the present findings, as preparation of the root canals and the thickness of dentin remaining can also affect the final resistance to fracture when the same obturation sealer is used. Thus, the use of standardisation of instrumentation parameters is still
necessary to compare the obturation techniques.[13]
The study presented further evidence in three sealers and three obturation methods for extracted roots of maxillary molars in 2025 experimental specimens. The researchers compared AH Plus, TotalFill bioceramic, and AH Plus bioceramic sealers with single-cone, warm vertical compaction, and Soft-Core techniques. In their investigation, they found that both the type of sealer and the obturation technique, when paired with each other, affected fracture resistance. This will emphasize the significance of having the same sealer composition in both groups of this study for minimizing the influence of material-related differences.[14]
Chellapilla et al. (2021) investigated the effect of various root filling materials and techniques on dentinal microcracks in root dentin using the micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) technique. They used 60 extracted mandibular premolars in their investigation, which involved comparing the cold lateral condensation, warm vertical condensation, and injectable gutta-percha methods. The authors noted that no significant increase in dentinal crack formation was found with warm vertical condensation.[9] The current study (p=0.223) showed a similar trend, with a higher crack incidence in warm vertical compaction, but not significant, with the current study finding a 1% difference. This finding is an important comparison with the present study, which recorded a similar trend, with a higher incidence of cracks in the warm vertical compaction, but not a significant difference (p=0.223), with a difference of 1% between the groups. The larger mean crack propagation length noted in the present results, however, is a different phenomenon from overall crack formation and should not be used to indicate that warm vertical compaction will necessarily result in more cracks.
Shantiaee et al. (2024) compared warm vertical compaction and two single-cone approaches using three-dimensional micro-CT assessment in curved root canals. They made their investigation not on fracture resistance but on the quality and distribution of the filling materials in root canals. However, it showed the usefulness of micro-CT in studying obturation properties and differences in filling adaptation. Their work is relevant to the present investigation because it supports the use of three-dimensional imaging for evaluating root canal filling characteristics, although filling quality and dentinal crack propagation should be regarded as distinct parameters.[15]
Ateyah et al. (2026) evaluated the fracture resistance of premolars filled with TotalFill BC Sealer by single cone obturation and TotalFill BC HiFlow Sealer by warm vertical compaction of gutta-percha. Their results showed differences in fracture resistance; however, the differences were not statistically significant. This result is consistent with the present study in which the single cone group had a numerically higher fracture resistance but not statistically significant (p=0.071). However, the different sealer formulations used in conjunction with different obturation techniques during their study precluded a complete isolation of the independent effect of the obturation technique.[16]
Özdemir et al. (2026) examined the fracture resistance of roots filled with bioceramic and resin-based sealers after various intracanal medication treatments. Results showed that there was a significant difference in terms of fracture resistance between bioceramic sealer groups and resin-based sealer groups.[17] The effect of filling methods and sealing materials on fracture resistance of maxillary central incisors with traumatic crown fractures was investigated by Dinçer et al. (2026). Their results showed that the choice of sealer and the obturation technique affected the resistance to fracture, and the combination of single-cone and TotalFill BC showed the highest numerical values. However, the studies employed different dental morphology, restorative techniques, and stress conditions, whereas this study did not. Thus, the results provide supportive evidence on the potential effect of obturation materials and methods, but cannot be directly compared with the fracture-load measurements obtained from mandibular premolars.[18]
Finally, Shetty et al. (2026 in a systematic review including 24 studies, mentioned that there were significant methodological variations in the studies evaluating the fracture resistance of endodontically treated teeth. The assessment showed similar mechanical efficacy between sealers based on calcium silicate and those based on epoxy resin, while pointing out that variations in tooth selection, obturation methods, and loading circumstances limited direct comparisons. These results support a conservative interpretation of the present results, especially as the study was conducted in a controlled laboratory environment and cannot fully replicate clinical chewing forces.[19]
The results of the present study showed that the single-cone method had a higher numerical fracture resistance and warm vertical compaction was associated with a significantly increased average crack propagation length. However, there were no significant differences in total number of cracks, duration of fracture, and patterns of fracture. Hence, the results fail to prove the superiority of any obturation method. They suggest that the assessment of endodontic obturation systems should consider mechanical durability along with dentin integrity. Further standardized studies with different tooth types, sealer compositions and extended cyclic loading are necessary to establish the clinical relevance of these laboratory results.
LIMITATIONS
The present study had particular limitations that should be taken into account when the results are analyzed. At first, the experiment was conducted in vitro on extracted human mandibular premolars, which may not fully reproduce the complex biological and functional conditions of the oral cavity. Secondly, differences in the inherent dentinal architecture, age-related changes, and pre-existing microscopic defects may have influenced the mechanical properties of individual samples, despite attempts to standardize tooth selection. Thirdly, the fracture resistance was evaluated by a static compressive loading method, which does not reproduce the repetitive and multidirectional forces of clinical mastication. Moreover, the study was conducted on one bioceramic sealer and two obturation techniques, which restricts the use of the results to other obturation materials and techniques. In the end, the experimental observation was too short to evaluate sustained changes in the dentinal integrity. Further investigations are recommended with more extensive samples, cyclic fatigue tests, different bioceramic compositions, and clinically relevant situations.
The in vitro study showed that the single-cone obturation technique was more resistant to fracture than warm vertical compaction, but the difference was not statistically significant. The warm vertical compaction cohort, however, had a significantly greater mean crack propagation length. However, the total number of dentinal cracks and the fracture patterns showed no significant difference between the groups. These results indicate that fracture resistance and crack propagation are different mechanical phenomena and should be assessed separately when assessing the obturation techniques. Neither method was statistically significantly better overall. Further studies in simulated clinical settings are needed to confirm the significance of these findings